Proposal to handle links to content uploaded to server.
Here's my proposal because I honestly think the 24 hour link expiration is honestly the stupidest shit ever, and I will put in bullet points:
- Instead of unnecessarily lengthening the link, keep it short and sweet. No dumb parameters, just follow the K.I.S.S. ("Keep It Simple" System). User convenience is IMPORTANT.
- Look into making sure that the content cannot be embedded outside of Discord. That is: I know there are methods, Photobucket (which is now the most hated image hosting ever) has theirs in that it adds a watermark and (if I recall) lowers the quality of embedded content
- Perhaps for this, have that embedded content instead uses a dummy image stating “This content cannot be displayed outside discord”
- Learn from imageshack: changing how links are interacted outside the site = bad. Before Photobucket “shat the bed”, Imageshack was considered the worst solely because they intentionally or otherwise created a file expiration by changing the link structure, and made sharing ANYTHING through it nonviable.
- If there's concern about people using Discord to share pirated stuff, give up trying to combat that. Because they ALWAYS find a way, and inconveniencing fair uses is not a solution to the problem.
- Additionally, There is a better approach to the matter OVERALL, and that is…SERVER SETTINGS! Really! Give server owners the ability to control how content in their server can be used out of it! Examples:
-
Generate Expiring Links: If ticked, any attempt to copy a link to the content will produce it with an expiration time or date. The time/date could be set by the server owner and range from 1 hour to 30 days, or could be set by the person when they choose “copy a link".
- Naturally, if this is turned on, opting to open it in browser will instead create a temporary link that lasts one hour at most.
-
Block Off-server Embedding: If ticked, any attempt to embed the content off Discord will produce a placeholder informing the content cannot be embedded as the server it came from disallows it.
- Perhaps there could also be an “Allowed Domains”, in case the server owner wants to allow the content to be embedded on specific domains.
-
Generate Expiring Links: If ticked, any attempt to copy a link to the content will produce it with an expiration time or date. The time/date could be set by the server owner and range from 1 hour to 30 days, or could be set by the person when they choose “copy a link".
- OK, I will concede to expiring links in full in ONE THING regardless of how bad the link length is: Direct Messages. Of course, because they are being shared in a private manner. But in these cases I'd say they should have an expiration time of 1 hour.
2
-
the way this will work from what im seeing is that, as long as the links are done inside they will work for ever, its off discord linking they want stopped
1
Accedi per aggiungere un commento.
Commenti
1 commento