Need way to hide list of members
Need way to hide list of members, need a way to make it so fresh non member users cannot see anyone in the discord except for admins. Not just hide online or offline members, fresh joins should be unable to view anyone in the server without permission
-
I help moderate a large discord server (37K+ users). We are constantly getting crypto scam/spam dm bots flooding our server, and DM'ing much of our users. If we were able to create a role that is applied to all users joining the server that prevents them from seeing users before they can verify that they are human, this would be a great help to large servers everywhere.
28 -
I want to use Discord for my class that's moving online unexpectedly, and I would if I could hide the students from being able to see (and therefore easily contact) a full list of all of the students in the class.
23 -
Same as @ProfDinkins Would be nice to have this as a role permission. We don't want students seeing other students.
16 -
Hello, i also need a way to hide the member list, this is a very important option i think for many owners of the group. Please add this option.
12 -
This is a much needed feature. I don't know why this is getting voted down.
11 -
I need to hide the member list from all the members except for the owner. I wish it were possible.
8 -
Hey team Discord,
I like to protect my users privacy and this list thing is not helping at all. My server is about investment and I manually approve everyone to be sure they are legit.
Here's the process :
1. User arrive on the discord server and has access to only one welcome channel. They have to click a small icon to create a ticket and introduce themselves.
2. After introduction and discussion they are approved (or not) and can access the rest of the Discord.
The problem is that all the verified users are visible from non verified users in the welcome channel. Spammers don't need to introduce themselves to have access to a list of people interested in investment.
I'm trying to protect my community and this is making it harder. Some of my community member are beginners, some are desperate (they want money), some are gullible. They are not all potential targets but no one like to receive spam.
Please give me the ability to protect my users, this is a much needed "feature" and I don't get why it's not activated for server that don't want to be "open to the world".
Thank you.7 -
I would also like to have a way to hide a list of members from regular users so that people can join without worrying about receiving unwarranted messages.
The comment about simply blocking users doesn't work for me because it is reactive and not proactive. I would prefer to have a system in place that would prevent users from getting unwarranted messages in the first place rather than having people complain - or just outright leave - and then having me go and address the issue.
Also, hiding a member list doesn't mean the member list is entirely obsolete. The member list would still function the same way; it's just people might not be able to view it, the same way you can hide channels from those that do not have the required roles.It would be like saying "why add a lock to your front door if you're just going to let people walk through the door anyways?"
5 -
+1
Ability to hide/toggle view for Member List and Channel List on individual client side would be much appreciated.
5 -
can we not make this happen i already had a few of my members complain about unsolicited messages from random people that joined something as simple as hiding the member list from a specific role would make a big difference please lets push for this to happen.
4 -
I would just like the ability to hide members, like a panel slider or collapse / extend ability so that i can increase my viewable area for reading information... Like twitch already does with its chat panel. you can collapse it to see more of the viewable screen
3 -
Bump because my community also needs this ability to protect privacy from those not verified or acknowledging community rules.
3 -
This seems like a simple and easy way to protect users, and to give admins the ability to keep their servers safe. Why in the world has it not been implemented yet? I, like so many others, have a genuine need for the ability to choose to hide server member lists from other members. If any user does NOT want to have their info hidden from others, that could still be accomplished if we had the ability to choose to hide the member list or not...but as it stands now, no one can make any choice at all regarding whether their name is displayed in a member list or not. Seems pretty silly to not give us that option; how about we fix that, considering so many users have been asking--begging!--for it, for at least a year? Thanks!
3 -
At our server with 32k members, we are suffering a lot with these crypto scam bots. Please, take some action on this.
We are using the trick to have a welcome channel and hide all channels to only people with a verified role, but it makes everything harder and removes our ability to use the nice new member greeting modal.
3 -
Yep this would we great
2 -
I'm running several servers for a game community where we have an external area for everyone and an internal area for alliance members.
It is crucial that the people in the external area don't see our online status because then they will know when to attack. Without being able to hide the member list for certain roles the only current alternative is to set your online status to invisible. This of course sets you invisible on all servers. Therefore this solution is not really optimal for our case.
2 -
My servers have been hit with the bot spamming stuff as well. This is a very important feature for privacy and protection.
2 -
If discord cannot hide members list then i have no use for it. I cannot afford to risk my clients info to scammers.
2 -
Desperately need a way to hide the member/userlist from members of a server, as me and a couple others are trying to figure a way to make a fully anonymous server.
Bots work for messages, but everyone would still be able to see who's in the server, which is a problem
Getting a toggle in the role permissions to "see user/memberlist" the same as you can toggle who can and can't tag everyone would be an immense help
2 -
This is an obligation I have a game server cluster and some ppl joins to my cluster discord group and sends pm from the user list to invite another servers, groups, etc. This is unacceptable I build a community but to not to feed other easy pickup trollers. I love Discord but not in this way. It's a very easy implementetion just give an option to Group Owners&Admins to show/hide user list. PLEASE FIX THIS!
2 -
We just did a post-mortem of the most recent attack on our server: https://blog.cryptohack.org/crypto-spambots-discord
In summary, the spamming self-bots had verified phone numbers (or a way to bypass the phone verification requirement). And it is likely that they can exploit the gateway Guild.query_members() functionality to pull an entire member list from a server even as an unverified account trapped in a single channel.
We've enabled screening as per TEEMAL's suggestion but it seems likely that these bots can bypass that too.
2 -
The best way for Discord to integrate this option would be through permissions, and this is why:
Still provides the original feature with a new option in a menu that already exists:- Frequently, Discord updates their permissions. They're capable of making new ones.
- This would be easy to navigate to, and it already exists, so why not create it there?
Adding it to permissions would also provide more features:
- The server settings menu would allow you to only prohibit a member in a specific role from showing up on the members list.
- This would allow channel and category specific selections as well by right clicking a channel or category.
- Channel/category specific permissions would also enable two additional features.
- Those features are selecting certain members, and of course, having channel specific permissions.
Why this would be useful:
- Servers may not want their bots to show on member lists, or their members DMing each other through the list.
- People may be taking advantage of fellow members seeing their profile in some way, shape or form.
- This could limit the list of members to special members like staff, boosters, etc. so servers can credit them.
2 -
I also would like to hide the member list from all the members except for the owner. Much needed feature.
1 -
yes please make members list on the right side collapsible. as well as make channels collapsible.
1 -
Much needed discord. I realy want to start building out my community but have concern for others people who just wish to take away from that effort for their own financial gain. Please help.
1 -
a simple checkbox when creating/managing each category/room would solve this. it could say something like, "show users who have access in userlist"
with the amount of garbage that is rampant on Discord, this seems like it should be a top priority..?
1 -
Unfortunately, that still doesn't work for me giantkin :( If you have a lot of people coming in at once, they can still see everyone who is in that initial room. Unless there's a way to automatically create new rooms when someone joins and assign them and admins there, but no one else and delete the room afterwards. I mean, I think that's theoretically possible...
1 -
Our guild has just 5k members but we would really like this feature. We are occasionally hit by cryptocurrency spammers who DM a large amount of our member list and annoy a lot of our users, some of whom leave Discord.
We have added phone verification and a bot captcha, but we suspect that these spammers are using one account (or hacked accounts) to pass the verification and obtain the user list, then feed it to fake accounts to send out all the DMs.
Currently we don't know what to do except recommend that users disable direct DMs from non-friends, but understandably a lot of people don't want to do that. I wish we had the ability to hide the member list instead as there's no real need to show all the online users to everyone who joins. It would be nice to be able to toggle this for different roles. Then we could protect our members from this spam.
1 -
Hasn’t been resolved at all. It’s honestly a safety concern for discord’s user base and makes discord look terrible growing a name for themselves as a spam haven. The devs are either being lazy or or ignorant or both in their timeliness of adding this as a feature and their responses to users.
1 -
Not seen any response from Discord on this topic. Seems like they just don't care.
My original concern is that Discord is open for people over 13, potentially got server with them along with adults.
What you don't want is adults inappropriately messaging minors. Its a massive child protection issue.
1
Por favor, entrar para comentar.
Comentários
78 comentários